Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Media balance

Much has been made of suggestions that John Key got more media coverage than Phil Goff in the last election.But it goes both ways as the Herald story demonstrates, Under the headline PM misled public on water ownership - Maori Council Adam Bennett writes:

Maori Council lawyer Felix Geiringer this morning challenged John Key's claim no one owns water and said the Prime Minister had misled the public on that point.
Justice Ronald Young is hearing in the High Court at Wellington the challenge to the Government's plan to partially privatise Mighty River Power next year taken by the council, the Waikato River and Dams Claims Trust and the Pouakani Claims Trust.
The council argues it is unlawful for the Government to sell shares in the company because that would affect the Government's ability to make redress for any Maori ownership claims over the Waikato River and other water bodies.
But Mr Key has dismissed the council's claims a number of times, saying his Government's view was that under common law no owned the water in rivers, lake and other water bodies.
But this morning Mr Geiringer said Mr Key was wrong, and his statements were an "error of law" and "meaningless".
Mr Geiringer said he believed Maori could potentially establish full blown ownership of water and his submissions included a number of examples of that.
But Mr Key's claim underpinned the three key decisions by his Government which the council is challenging in court which were;
# the decision to convert Mighty River Power into a "mixed ownership model" company which can be partially privatised,
# the decision not proceed with "Shares Plus" or any other mechanism for redressing Maori proprietary rights in water, and,
# the final decision to partially sell the company which is expected next year.
But Mr Geiringer said Mr Key had misled the public on the ownership of water.
"It's tricksy on behalf of the Prime Minister who pretended to the New Zealand public that he was basing his decision on the common law that no one owned the water when he wasn't really.
"In secret the Crown knew that it was possible to own water and therefore that formed no part of their decision-making but that's not what he told New Zealand."

Mr Geiringer is, of course, the paid spokesman for the Maori Council, and as a lawyer it is his job to articulate his client's argument. The Herald gives plenty of column space to that argument.

The Herald however gives far less space to Justice Ronald Young's response to Mr Geiringer's advocacy; read on:

However, Justice Young challenged Mr Geiringer's claims, asking him repeatedly to explain how Mr Key's statements were an error of law. That led to a heated exchange which ended only when Justice Young told an increasingly frustrated Mr Geiringer to" take a deep breath and count to 10" and to "remember where you are".

Oh dear. Justice Young can apparently see right through the Maori Council's kite-flying exercise, but that of course is far less newsworthy than unsubstantiated and unflattering references to the Prime Minister. Based on comments we have seen from journalists attending this hearing, the Maori Council's application seems destined to fail.

And as an afterthought, Phil Goff's claims of media bias during the 2011 election campaign are as much a kite-flying exercise as the Maori Council's legal challenge to the Crown. The 80 photos of Mr Goff that Claire Robinson found were 80 photographs more of him than his strategic genii would allow to appear on Labour's election campaign billboards.

1 comment:

Louise Perkins said...

John Key mislead the New Zealand public repeatedly when he promised us a Brighter Future.
Of course he mislead us on other issues. It's how he operates.